Personally, I’m a Sally’s girl through and through. Every year after the New Haven St. Patrick’s parade, my parents would bring my sister and I to Sally’s for a celebratory pie. I fell in love with their scrumptious white clam pie. So, seeing their name so high on this year’s list brings tiny sparks of joy to my cold dead heart. But while Pepe’s somehow clinches the title of having the best clam pie, their “tomato pie […] has the original beat.” Plus, their crispy crunchy thin crust is a delicacy all in itself.
Image Credit: tfoxfoto / iStock / Getty Images Plus / Getty